Is it illegal for my boss to give me extra flexible hours because I'm a new mum?

The situation

I am currently working as a junior administrator at a medium-sized firm in Melbourne, Victoria. Since returning from maternity leave last month, following the birth of my daughter in January, I have been struggling to balance my shifts with my childcare arrangements. My manager, Sarah, noticed I was struggling during our catch-up on the 15th of last month. To help me out, she has offered to let me work from home two days a week and has adjusted my start time from 8:30 am to 10:00 am, even though the rest of the team has to be in the office early. She also mentioned that I can take longer breaks to deal with breastfeeding schedules. One of my colleagues, who has no children, heard about this and complained to HR yesterday, claiming that it is unfair treatment and that we should all be following the same standard contract terms. I have already spoken to Sarah, and she insists she is just trying to support me, but now I am worried. Is it actually against the law for my employer to provide these specific adjustments for me because of my new family responsibilities, or can my coworker claim I am being treated unfairly?

Detailed Analysis

It is not illegal for Sarah to offer you these adjustments. In fact, the law specifically allows for what are called 'special measures.' A special measure is an action taken to help a specific group of people reach a level playing field with others^[1].

According to the Sex Discrimination Act, a person may take special measures for the purpose of "achieving substantive equality between: ... (e) women who are breastfeeding and people who are not breastfeeding; or (f) people with family responsibilities and people without family responsibilities"^[1]. Substantive equality means making sure the outcome is fair, even if the rules aren't identical for everyone. Because Sarah is adjusting your hours and location to help you manage breastfeeding and childcare, she is using these permitted measures to support you.

Furthermore, the law states that "A person does not discriminate against another person ... by taking special measures authorised by subsection (1)"^[1]. This means that even though your colleague feels the treatment is unfair because it deviates from standard contract terms, Sarah's actions do not constitute illegal discrimination.

Regarding your colleague's complaint, the law focuses on whether the employer is using these measures to achieve equality for those with specific needs. While your colleague is entitled to follow the standard contract, they do not have a legal right to demand that you be treated exactly the same if you have different needs, such as breastfeeding or childcare responsibilities.

It is important to note that while Sarah's support is legal, the specific way these changes are documented might matter. Under the Fair Work Act, if these changes are part of an 'individual flexibility arrangement' (an agreement to vary the effect of a modern award to meet genuine needs), there are specific rules about how they must be written and signed^[2].

Statutory Citations

Related Questions

• Can my boss punish me for reporting sexual harassment at work?
• Can my boss fire me if I take a side job to pay off my debts?
• Is it illegal for a job ad to lie about the hourly pay and hours?
• Can I take legal action if my boss treats me differently because of my background?
• Can my boss punish me for making a formal complaint about racism at work?